“It was the mark of a barbarian to destroy something one could not understand.” – Arthur C. Clarke
CBDCs: What Brazil can teach the EU
Term of the day: Section 301
Macro: US CPI
Crypto is Macro Now offers ~daily commentary and updates on the overlap between the crypto and macro landscapes. Plus links and more.
If you’re a premium subscriber, thank you so much!! ❤
Solana accounts for 12% of onchain RWA market cap, but 32% of RWA spot volume. Allium Research worked with Solana to look beyond assets issued and ask a different question: how are RWAs being used onchain? The full report maps 37 issuers across fixed income, private funds, equities, commodities and active strategies, and looks at where issuance, ownership and trading are actually happening.
Read the full report: https://allium.so/reports/solana-rwa-ecosystem
And get weekly onchain data and more analysis like this from the Allium Research team on Substack.
Hello everyone! I hope you’re all taking care of yourselves. A heavy day today, for those that remember… After 25 years, it still feels recent.
If you missed yesterday’s email, check out the first episode of a new video/podcast series: Stablecoins Around the World.
While the European Central Bank is spending considerable political and monetary capital on developing a digital euro that most of us don’t want, Brazil has the Pix system.
Created and operated by the central bank (Banco Central do Brasil, or BCB), it enables near-instant 24/7 payments by connecting bank accounts behind the interface. There is no Pix app – rather, Pix powers commercial bank apps and digital wallets. Recipients are identified by their Pix key which is the same throughout the system and means senders don’t have to type in full banking details. Transfers between individuals are free, and relatively low for businesses.
Although it launched just six years ago, Pix today has more than 170 million users, roughly 80% of the total population. This past December, almost 90% of Brazilian adults used Pix at least once. Cash use is dropping sharply, even though Pix also facilitates the withdrawal of cash without a card via participating merchants and ATMs. By all accounts, it has been phenomenally successful.
And it is popular: there appears to be relatively little concern over central bank control and the possibility that the system’s ubiquity creates a dependency. Rather, concern is more about protecting access. There is currently a constitutional amendment under consideration by the Brazilian parliament that would give the BCB exclusive power to regulate and operate Pix, would ban its transfer to another private or public entity, and would enshrine free use for individuals.
Here is what Pix is not: it is not a CBDC, despite Paul Krugman’s insistence to the contrary (bewildering, really). Pix is a payments rail. It does not change the nature of money, nor the relationship between the central bank and consumers, nor the relationship between consumer banks and their clients. It moves digital reals, but it does not create them nor represent them.
And yet, it has managed to reduce Brazil’s dependence on US platforms while broadening financial inclusion.
Yes, those are the very same targets espoused by the European Central Bank (ECB) in its push for a CBDC. It has positioned its digital euro project as the only way to defend European interests against US hegemony in the form of payment platform dominance (Visa, Mastercard, etc.) and the likely popularity of dollar stablecoins.
Brazil shows that there are less intrusive, more popular ways to do so.
It also highlights the CBDC trilemma: a trade-off between efficiency, programmability and privacy.
