Now that the Democrats have the greatest mandate in half a century to govern in the legislature, they need to understand what the American people expect them to do with that victory.
Americans gave them control of the House and Senate. They’ll have the power to investigate this administration, demand answers and force votes. They asked people to turn out. People did. Now they owe those voters something more than a press conference about how concerned they are.
That starts with choosing leaders who understand the fuckin assignment.
Hakeem Jeffries is expected to become speaker. He’ll have to answer for what the House does under his leadership. In the Senate, Chuck Schumer wants his old job back.
And I think it’s time for him to help somebody else take it.
Asked on The Daily about making room for younger leaders, Schumer described himself as “sort of the conductor.” His colleagues have different talents, he explained, and his job is to keep them working together.
Okay, Chuck. Who are you teaching to conduct?
Because if the answer is that you’re the only person who can do it, what exactly have you been building all these years?
I understand the argument for keeping Schumer. He knows the Senate. He knows his members. He understands the rules, the personalities and the negotiations. Running a caucus takes more than getting on television and telling people you’re ready to fight.
But all that experience should make him capable of preparing a successor. He should be able to say: Here’s what I know. Here’s what you need to watch out for. Here’s how I can help you succeed.
That would be leadership. I’d respect it.
Instead, Democrats are being asked to accept that the safest choice is to keep relying on the same person, for the same reasons, until some undefined point when the next generation is finally ready.
They’re going to need a chance to do the job.
Sen. Chris Van Hollen meets with Kilmar Ábrego García in El Salvador on April 17, 2025. Photo via the Office of Sen. Chris Van Hollen (public domain).
Chris Van Hollen is somebody I’d take seriously. Before the Senate, he served in House leadership and as the top Democrat on the House Budget Committee. He has experience with the money, the legislation and the work required to get something through Congress.
He’s said he isn’t pursuing the leadership job. I wish he’d reconsider.
I’d like to hear his plan for this majority. How would he use it to investigate corruption? How would he deal with an administration that refuses to cooperate? What would he demand for working people when the next spending negotiation comes around?
Those are questions every candidate should have to answer. Van Hollen has enough experience that nobody can reasonably dismiss him as someone who needs another decade watching from the sidelines.
Chris Murphy should be part of the conversation, too. His work negotiating the 2022 bipartisan gun legislation gives him a serious answer to anyone who says younger Democrats can talk but can’t deliver. Even Schumer credited his leadership in reaching that agreement.
But Murphy just suffered a stroke. He’s been discharged from the hospital and is continuing his recovery in rehabilitation. His doctor has said he’s expected to make a full recovery.
His health comes first. Full stop.
He deserves the time and privacy to recover without people turning that recovery into a leadership audition. Any discussion of taking on this job has to respect what he wants and what his doctors advise. We can recognize what he has to offer without putting another demand on him while he’s getting well.
Brian Schatz deserves a look as well. He’s already chief deputy whip and deputy conference secretary, and he serves on Appropriations. He has experience inside the leadership operation and with the spending decisions that give Congress much of its power.
If knowing how the place works is the qualification, then explain why his experience doesn’t count.
These senators would have to earn their colleagues’ support. I’m not pretending that naming them means they have the votes or even want to run. I’m saying Democrats have credible people to consider, and they ought to consider them before deciding the discussion is over.
Schumer’s supporters will say he helped win this majority.
Give him credit. Winning matters.
So does knowing when to hand over responsibility. He could help a new leader succeed while continuing to serve New York. His knowledge doesn’t disappear because somebody else gets the office.
Others will warn that a leadership contest could divide the party.
Democrats can handle a few days of explaining what they believe and how they intend to govern. The incoming senators should get to speak. The people who just won difficult races should get to explain what they heard from voters before everyone is told to fall in line.
Voters line up at Pennypack Elementary School in Hatboro, Pennsylvania, on November 3, 2020. Photo by Dough4872 (CC BY-SA 4.0).
I want unity around a plan people can hold them to.
I want to know which abuses they’re going to investigate, how they’re going to pursue the evidence and what they’ll do when somebody ignores a subpoena. I want deadlines. I want follow-through. When the evidence warrants consequences, I want leaders prepared to pursue them.
I’ve spent years hearing politicians say that nobody is above the law. I’d like to see them make that statement mean something.
That applies to Jeffries, too. The speaker’s office comes with responsibility. If House Democrats uncover misconduct, leadership needs to back the work all the way through, including impeachment where the evidence warrants it. Senate Democrats need to take their own constitutional responsibilities just as seriously.
And while they’re doing that, people still have bills to pay. They need affordable health care, housing they can afford and wages that give them a chance to get ahead. Democrats need an agenda that puts those needs first, and leaders who can explain how they intend to deliver it.
Of course Trump can veto legislation. Of course the Senate has rules and obstacles. Whoever leads should explain those limits honestly, then tell us what they’re going to do about them.
I don’t expect a majority leader to perform miracles. I expect one to use the power they have and make the people obstructing progress answer for it.
Being younger doesn’t automatically make somebody courageous or effective. But Democrats cannot keep postponing succession and then complain that nobody else is ready.
Schumer has an opportunity here. He can help choose the future of his party, share what he knows and give a new leader the support to succeed.
Chuck, you’ve told us how talented your colleagues are.
Trust one of them with the baton.