Chuck Schumer took a LOT of shit during the 2026 election cycle.
“Schumer faces renewed scrutiny after Mills meltdown” screamed a Politico headline in late April.
“Mills Exit Is a Blow to Schumer as Democrats Question His Strategy,” read a New York Times article around the same time.
That Times piece included this damning paragraph:
The high-stakes mess in Maine reflected a disconnect between Mr. Schumer, an establishment figure, and many other Democrats both on Capitol Hill and around the country who worry that he is too conventional and out of touch with the progressive energy inside his party to continue as its leader. For them, Ms. Mills’s exit was proof that Mr. Schumer does not understand what is animating Democratic voters, and what is turning them off.
So bad did things get for Schumer that some sitting Democratic Senators — most notably New Mexico’s Martin Heinrich — called on him to step aside as leader. And, on the campaign trail, opposing Schumer became a liberal litmus test in Democratic primaries — with the likes of Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan and Troy Jackson in Maine (among others) saying they wouldn’t vote for the New York Senator as party leader.
Even AFTER the election on Tuesday, Jon Stewart was blasting Schumer.
One of the first things you need to do is remove that system of seniority from Democratic politics. It is a b——- system, and it needs to go. … (People are) already like, ‘Chuck Schumer deserves a lot of credit for putting together this (victory). … Enough. Chuck Schumer fought tooth and nail against half of these f—— people, and even if he didn’t, he does not understand the urgency of the moment and what the future demands.
Stewart is, of course, entitled to his own opinions. But he is not entitled to his own facts. And the facts are very clear: Chuck Schumer won on Tuesday night. Bigly.
Let me explain.
Start here: Democrats netted seven seats — and are likely winners in two more (Alaska and Mississippi). Let’s go through Schumer’s role in each of the nine races — and grade him, shall we?
Schumer was intimately involved in recruiting former Democratic Rep. Mary Peltola into the race. As Axios wrote back in January on the eve of Peltola’s announcement:
Landing Peltola in Alaska would give Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer another opportunity to go on offense in 2026, as he looks[to recruit his]way out of a difficult map.
Schumer has been trying to convince Peltola to plunge into the race since the summer and sees a plausible path to victory.
Peltola was widely seen as the only Democrat with the statewide profile to beat Sen. Dan S. Sullivan. Which she seems to be on track to do:
While Schumer didn’t endorse in the primary fight between state Rep. Josh Turek and state Sen. Zach Wahls, he made pretty clear who he thought was the better general election candidate. VoteVets, a super PAC with ties to Schumer that backs military veterans, spent more than $2 million on ads touting Turek in advance of the June primary — a TV blitz credited with delivering Turek the nomination. (Turek is not a military vet.)
In the general election, 𝕏Schumer’s Senate Majority PAC spent $67 million on TV ads for Turek (and against GOP Rep. Ashley Hinson) — despite the fact that Donald Trump carried the state by 13 points in 2024.
Adam Hamilton, the pastor who ousted Sen. Roger Marshall in the the Sunflower State last Tuesday, was not recruited into the contest by Schumer nor did the New York Democrat play any role in helping Hamilton win the August primary, according to a knowledgeable Democratic Senate source.
But, Senate Majority PAC did spend $14 million to back Hamilton’s general election bid — a not-insignificant investment given that Kansas last elected a Democrat to the Senate in 1932.
Hamilton has said he will not support Schumer for Senate Majority Leader. “I mean no disrespect for Chuck Schumer,” Hamilton said on “Meet The Press” this past weekend. “And I’ve told him that as well. But I think, at least where I live in Kansas, he is kind of a polarizing figure.”
Schumer thought he had secured a top recruit when sitting Gov. Janet Mills got into the race — at his urging — in late 2025. “Chuck Schumer gets his preferred candidate, Janet Mills, in crowded Maine Senate race,” read a Politico headline at the time.
Mills, who had been state Attorney General before spending eight years as governor, was a poor match for a political environment that prized outsiders. She dropped from the race in late April when it became clear that she was headed to an embarrassing loss at the hands of oyster farmer Graham Platner.
As I noted at the top of the piece, Schumer was widely blasted for betting on Mills — a sign, many liberals argued, that he was no longer the right man to lead Senate Democrats.
Platner’s subsequent implosion — and decision, under duress, to abandon his candidacy — seemed to affirm, at least for some, Schumer’s concerns about him as a candidate. Schumer stayed out of the race to replace Platner as the Democratic nominee.
Troy Jackson, who won the nomination and then beat Sen. Susan Collins last week, has pledged not to support Schumer.
Eighteen months ago, the only Democrat in Washington who thought Mississippi could be competitive was Schumer.
As the New York Times noted back in May:
Senator Chuck Schumer, the New York Democrat and minority leader who plays a central role in mapping his party’s Senate campaign strategy, has long been intrigued by the prospect of competing in Mississippi. He met with Mr. Colom multiple times in recent years in an effort to recruit him.
“This is a good year to expand the map, and Mississippi is a long shot,” Mr. Schumer said. “Still, if it’s ever going to be doable, this is the year.”
In the general election, under pressure from black lawmakers, Schumer’s Senate Majority PAC𝕏 dropped more than $2 million on ads in the state, which Trump won in 2024 by 23(!) points.
Colom now leads Sen. Cindy Hyde Smith by almost 3,000 votes and assesses that: “The shifts and totals so far heavily indicate that Scott Colom will be the next senator.”
This race was non-competitive — Sen.-elect Roy Cooper beat Michael Whatley by almost 20(!) points — but it’s important to note why it was such a cakewalk: Schumer got Cooper in early and united the party behind him.
Here’s Axios all the way back in July 2025:
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) landed his top 2026 recruit in former North Carolina Gov.[Roy Cooper], giving Democrats some midsummer hope they can steal a GOP Senate seat next year.
Would Cooper have run with or without Schumer’s urging? Probably. But Schumer gets credit for knowing who Democrats’ strongest candidate was and getting him into the race.
Schumer served for decades with Sherrod Brown prior to the latter’s loss in 2024. With J.D. Vance’s Senate seat up in 2026, Schumer recruited Brown early and often.
As he recounted to “The Daily” in an interview last week, he repeatedly visited with Brown and his wife, Connie Schultz, a Pulitzer Prize winning columnist, in Ohio. And in his last visit, Schumer landed Brown by making the point that if Democrats lost the Senate by a single seat in 2026, the former Senator (and his wife) would be devastated — and blame themselves.
According to an interview Sen.-elect Annie Andrews did with Politico’s Jonathan Martin, Schumer wasn’t involved in her recruitment or her race against Sen. Darline Graham — until the the final weeks.
And, Andrews has said she will not vote for Schumer to lead Democrats in the 120th Congress. “It is time for a generational change on both sides of the aisle,” Andrews told Fox News’ Bret Baier after her victory last week.
In Schumer’s defense: He did direct $750,000 to Andrews’ campaign from Senate Majority PAC in the final weeks of the race. (And ask yourself: Would Andrews have wanted a bunch of national Democratic money pouring into a state that Trump won by 18 points in 2024?)
Schumer purposely stayed out of the March primary fight between Rep. Jasmine Crockett and state Rep. James Talarico.
And, he was somewhat slow to acknowledge that Texas was real — regularly failing to list it as one of the party’s top pickup opportunities. (I, personally, think Schumer gets something of a pass for his skepticism; Democrats hadn’t won ANY statewide seat in Texas since 1994!)
But, money talks. And Senate Majority PAC wound up dumping $40 million into Texas on Talarico’s behalf. While that was dwarfed by how much the Senate Leadership Fund, the main Senate Republican super PAC, spent on Texas, it’s still $40 million that Schumer could have chosen to spend in more friendly Democratic seats/states.
In the nine likely pickups for Senate Democrats in the 2026 election, Schumer’s report card looks like this:
A+: 4
A-: 2
B: 2
D:1
That’s pretty damn good!
Now, it’s worth pointing out that in Michigan, one of three Democratic seats up in 2026 regarded as vulnerable, Schumer picked the wrong horse.
Schumer endorsed Rep. Haley Stevens in her primary race against Abdul El-Sayed back in June. “I think she has the best chance to win,” Schumer told Punchbowl News at the time.
Not only did El-Sayed win the primary— albeit very narrowly — but Stevens wound up endorsing former Rep. Mike Rogers, the Republican Senate nominee, in the final days of the race.
I will note here that El-Sayed was one of only three Democrats running for Senate in competitive races who 𝕏underperformed the expected Democratic performance in their races:
While there is a lot noise from the left about getting rid of Schumer, I think the New York Democrat actually deserves to be overwhelmingly re-elected to the top job next month.
And his colleagues — or at least enough of them — appear to agree.
Here’s the New York Times over the weekend:
Twenty months later and in the wake of a sweeping electoral victory he engineered and funded, Mr. Schumer’s aides say he has locked down another term in that post, having secured commitments of support from enough Democratic senators to be elected majority leader in a private vote scheduled for next month.
Do I think Schumer has solved all of his political problems? Absolutely not! If Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez decides to challenge him in 2028 for the Democratic Senate nomination, I think he likely loses. (My guess is Schumer would retire rather than lose.)
But, it’s very clear to me that Schumer deserves the lion’s share of credit for where Senate Democrats stand today.
You can hate him. Or love him. But the facts are facts.