Trump took to Bari’s Weiss’ propaganda channel to speak his truth that earning $3 B in his second term makes him like everyone else. He’s not completely inhumane, though. Since people didn’t like his paramilitary force killing people, it was a step too far. X predictably was on fire about his weakness and fairly silent about his grift. Why? Because stupidity is acceptable, but stopping cruelty is not. Cruelty leaves no room for empathy or thought.
The last decade has been an exercise in out-stupiding the previous stance. Turning trans in school, eating cats and dogs, women being attacked by trans women in bathrooms--believing the dumbest thing was a badge of dis-honor.
Underlying much of the stupidity, though, is a clear media literacy challenge. Since the earliest human-written system, we can see that when powerful people hope to move the masses into line, they foment fear.
Fear is an irrational force that is easily stirred, particularly given the many uncertainties of human existence. Monumental figures of beasts were meant to strike fear into the heart of any traveler walking into Persepolis. Amenhotep erected monumental sculptures to keep everyone fully aware of who was in charge, but they also reminded people of the power he chose not to wield. So much historical sculpture was about the potential might held in check. Be good or else, those enormous statues said.
Fear is a great motivator for acquiescence and order. But it’s not a motivator for growth and change. So much of the American experiment comes from the Enlightenment, in which liberty and learning were the engine of thought, channeled into capitalism. Profit is stalled by stupidity and fear.
Trump’s business acumen was a figment of reality television instead of lived experience. He was able to fool people for many reasons: FOX television’s hold on the dumbest sector of Americans by amping up their irrational fear of life, an increasingly challenging and fractured cultural discourse created by the rise of personal content creators, and a workforce that had shifted to knowledge work. The dumbest people were increasingly unable to keep up with online communication or find meaningful work but had FOX News to keep them in thrall with fear culture. A misguided population was just waiting to be heard by an important man.
Unfailingly, Trump’s adherents call him Mr. Trump, dropping the salutation for Obama or Clinton. Bush didn’t get such an honor either. Trump, however, speaks like a poorly educated man, but he’s clearly wealthy. His perceived stupidity was a strong differentiator for his audience. He’s like the rich man who’d sit down for McDonald’s with the guys, except in reality, he’s not. He’ll have McD’s but not with regular people. The disconnect between his persona and his actions, though, is hard to discern if you’re dysregulated emotionally from your 24/7 hate engine. But their use of Mr. draws on a vestigial cultural element not unlike never calling a King by his first name alone. In their speech, they retain the honorific for the man they perceive as powerful.
As the midterms unfolded, though, Trump’s shine had long tarnished. After the elections, rather than seeing a repudiation, Trump saw a chance to shine personally, with his decorating prowess. Where everyone else saw a failure of monumental proportions, he saw a chance to cement his legacy.
There’s a huge difference between Amenhotep and Trump — the Pharaoh was exceptionally successful. Amenhotep ushered in unprecedented prosperity, so he had the wherewithal to erect all those enormous statues. Trump’s plans to put himself on Mount Rushmore or erect a victory arch are based on buzz that’s fizzled.
Another big difference is that in ancient history no one profited off stupidity. Yes, ancient Egyptians weren’t literate, even Pharaohs. But people’s working knowledge was essential to their family’s survival. No one wants an unskillful potter, and that potter won’t eat if they don’t shape up (pun intended). Work knowledge was also not connected to class. You were born to a segment of society. Being smart or talented wasn’t a factor in your mobility (there wasn’t any).
By the Enlightenment, intelligence helped fuel some mobility (for white men). For the first 200 years of this country, being an idiot was not a badge of honor. The system shifted when the head start of being a white man started lifting. Rather than focus on keeping up with women, POC, Black people, white men leaned into intractable stupidity as a defining feature of Americanness. Trump’s current term shows how when American Exceptionalism is a slogan in direct opposition to the way that the American economy runs, we become an international joke.
We need to stop every overture Trump makes to continue to enshrine his stupidity in the built landscape of our nation. Any visualization of Trump’s term is a testament to the depths of stupidity this country has delved.
As a culture, we need to beat back the culture of stupidity. Not a war on ignorance, in the same way you can’t fuck for virginity, but instead a concerted culture of change, where thought and action become central to our national culture. Then the monuments we create will be the lived ones of a better world.