🗳️ How Scott Colom won
Back in April, I interviewed Scott Colom, the Mississippi Democrat who just pulled off one of the biggest upsets in Senate history — defeating GOP Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith in a state Donald Trump carried by 23 points in 2024.
Back in April, I interviewed Scott Colom, the Mississippi Democrat who just pulled off one of the biggest upsets in Senate history — defeating GOP Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith in a state Donald Trump carried by 23 points in 2024.
Back in April, I interviewed Scott Colom, the Mississippi Democrat who just pulled off one of the biggest upsets in Senate history — defeating GOP Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith in a state Donald Trump carried by 23 points in 2024.
I wanted to re-surface that interview in the wake of Colom’s victory — and the Associated Press called the race for him on Wednesday night — for a few reasons:
Colom had a plan — and a theory of the case — way back in April about how he could win.The interview gives you a strong sense of what sort of approach Colom will take to his new gig as a senatorI wanted people to know that I was watching this race MONTHS ago — and wasn’t just pretending I knew all about it when it was close on Election Day 😂😂
So, enjoy the interview with the first black Senator from Mississippi since Reconstruction.
— Chris
To hear Scott Colom tell it, Mississippi Republican Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith is nowhere to be found in the Magnolia State.
“She hasn’t done a town hall in six years,” Colom, a district attorney and the Democratic nominee against Hyde-Smith, told me in a Substack Live Wednesday. “I did more town halls last week than she’s done the entire time in this term of the United States Senate.”
Hyde-Smith is notoriously low profile. Since being appointed to the Senate to replace then Sen. Thad Cochran in 2018, she has largely kept her head down — and been one of the most reliable votes for President Donald Trump’s agenda.
It hasn’t hurt her electorally. In 2020, former Democratic Rep. Mike Espy attacked Hyde-Smith for being a senator in absentia; “She’s doing the same thing the rest of the country often does — ignoring Mississippi,” Espy said. “She’s running a lazy campaign, taking voters for granted. You don’t do that in Mississippi.”
Hyde-Smith won by 10 points as Trump was winning the state by 17. (In 2024, Trump won Mississippi by 23 points.)
Those Trump margins don’t tell the true story of the competitiveness of the state, according to Colom. He rightly notes that Gov. Tate Reeves only won reelection by three points in 2023 and that Espy only lost the 20218 special election to Hyde-Smith by 8 points.
“The people of Mississippi know the dirty little secret that hasn’t really penetrated the national environment,” Colom told me. “We are a competitive state.”
Fair enough. The large African-American population — black voters comprise more than 35% of the entire state — makes the state potentially appealing to national Democrats because it’s very easy to see how ANY nominee can get into the mid 40s.
It’s why Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer has long had an eye on the Magnolia State as a potential sleeper for his side. A New York Times piece last May noted that “party strategists are also thinking outside the box, looking for political lottery tickets in places like Alaska, Mississippi and Texas.”
Despite Schumer’s interest and Colom’s unstinting optimism, it is a VERY heavy lift. The last Democrat to win a Senate race in Mississippi was John Stennis when he got re-elected in 1982. Which was [checks calendar] 44 years ago.
At the moment, the rates Mississippi as a “Solid Republican” race.
Send this story to anyone — or drop the embed into a blog post, Substack, Notion page. Every play sends rev-share back to So What.
We’ve simplified responses to 👍 / 👎. Past comments are archived but no longer visible.