I haven’t written much lately about my federal parking case, so this is a good time for an update. While the main lawsuit is pending in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida, I recently had a separate skirmish in Palm Beach County traffic court involving a Town of Palm Beach $75 parking ticket. I challenged the ticket, showed up ready to fight it, and in the end I won. The Town’s certified parking enforcement specialist, who had been subpoenaed, showed up the first time and never showed up the second time. The case was dismissed.
Now, to be clear, that dismissal was in county traffic court, not federal court. It doesn’t decide the larger issues in my lawsuit, and it doesn’t prove that the Town’s signs are illegal. But it is still an interesting little victory, especially when the person bringing the ticket is the same person challenging the parking system itself in federal court. When the witness is under subpoena and fails to appear, when there was a good chance that the Traffic Hearing Officer was going to rule on the merits of the case, then please feel free to draw you own conclusions.
What we do know is simple. The Town issued the ticket. I contested it. Their witness failed to appear. The case was dismissed. That is not speculation. That is what happened. Whether the no-show was just carelessness, indifference, or something more strategic, I’ll leave to others, but I can tell you this much: when you start asking hard questions about parking signs, app-only systems, legal authority, and public coercion disguised as convenience, cities and towns tend to get a little uncomfortable.
That is why this fight matters. My federal case is not about one ticket and it is not about sour grapes. It is about whether cities and towns are allowed to make up parking systems as they go along, force people into private apps, hide behind noncompliant signs, and then punish the public for failing to navigate a system that often seems designed to confuse rather than inform. I have said from the beginning that if government is going to enforce the law against us, then it had better follow the law itself. That principle shouldn’t be controversial, but apparently in the parking world it is revolutionary.
If you want to follow or support the larger fight, here is the fundraiser for the federal case: Federal Lawsuit Takes On America’s Parking Scam. I’ve been financing this battle largely out of my own pocket, and if this case is going to keep moving forward the right way, with the right support, then every bit helps. If you believe government should have to obey the same laws it enforces against the rest of us, take a look.
So yes, I fought the ticket and I won. Small victory? Maybe. But victories have a way of adding up, and this one comes with a message. The parking people are not used to being challenged. They are even less used to being challenged by someone who reads the statutes, studies the MUTCD, subpoenas witnesses, and refuses to roll over. If you’d like to support the larger battle, here again is the link: Support the federal lawsuit here.