If you were one of the nearly 130,000 people impacted by the 12-hour shortage that Microsoft acknowledged, or the millions they’re pretending they didn’t impact, you probably have too many emails this AM to read this, but later, as you relax into thinking about retribution and only have TEAMS for half a work day, know that the error was completely human. Similarly, if you feel duped by luxury brands that claim couture while using AI in ads, that was a very human mistake. Machines don’t choose to be used (well, in these instances). People are at fault, and it goes back to how we define handmade and machine-made.
We’re sometimes described as being in the fourth Industrial Age. While the Industrial Revolution is often taught in schools as the period in the 19th century when machines got power from electricity, the story of industrialization is more complex. People have been using tools to scale work for eons. Most of the soldiers for the first emperor's tomb were built using molds in an early way that Artisans could build quickly. Using piece molds, different forms for faces, bodies, and legs gave them the appearance of infinite variations. Complex looms made fabric quicker. Until the 18th century, machines largely helped workers with their existing tasks, but were not meant to displace humans.
Large-scale mechanization hit the fabric industry first. Mechanized looms brought small-scale, family-company-style work into the wage-labor system. These looms still needed people, but many fewer. While this fabric allowed more people to have more clothing, the cost was not considerably lower. Once steam power and electricity were hooked up to the machines, even fewer people were needed, and prices fell. In this era, human labor became seen as expendable. It’s not that in serfdom, the lords were so noble as to preserve opportunities for people. It’s simply that until electricity, there was no way for the wealthy to get the work done without people.
Automation in the 20th century, coupling computers with electricity and machines, decreased the need for people once again. In each of these phases, while the number of people needed decreased, the skills of those who worked in these roles often needed to increase. Historically, tapestries were woven by scores and scores of workers with highly specialized skills for that role. Once machines took over, coupled with electricity and automation, humans still needed to understand tapestry weaving and solve technical issues beyond the loom. Wages also consistently decreased as industrialization increased. The automation boom of the 20th century coincided with many factories moving to Asia. This Reagan-era switcheroo made American consumers think machines alone were producing the cheap crap they were buying. But really, humans were still making those items; however, they were Asian and being paid cents on the American dollar.
Which brings up an interesting conceit in American consumer products. Almost every textile you wear has a lot of human labor, but if it is cheaply made, we are most likely going to assume it’s machine-made. The hands that were part of the labor system are rendered invisible so as to assuage any moral quandary the Western consumer might have about the conditions of the people making their clothes.
The invisible labor in Sweatshop production is essentially why Microsoft went down. We have decreased the value of Labor in many sectors. Pink-collar work means that when a sector, like teaching or Pediatrics, is largely done by women, wages are lower. Ensuring the next generation is both educated and healthy has an incredible value to society. Wages are not based on the importance of the role but on the gender of the people doing it. Just as cheap Asian labor is ignored in the Sweatshop example, the work of women has historically been undervalued.
In a system where labor is valued so erratically, people in top positions assume their wages and skills are equivalent. C-suite people believe the hype that they deserve their earnings while undervaluing everyone else. Why? Our hierarchical system implies that high wages equal high intelligence. In all likelihood, nepotism or patriarchy placed those men in the top positions at Microsoft. Those managers might have had the skills for their particular role, but hubris and magical thinking led them to decide to let go of 60,000 employees to be replaced by AI. Many managers oversee staff who do work they have not done directly. It takes humility to understand that you might excel in some things but don’t know everything. Studies have shown, though, that many male managers have a blind spot, assuming their specialized knowledge is broadly useful. Basically, the leaders at Microsoft Dunning-Krugered everyone into a shutdown of outlook. The value of labor hasn't mattered for 150 years, so they did what was best for shareholders, not for the product.
Dior made a similar mistake. But their gaffe was even more laughable. Luxury brands have been trying to remind everyone how distinctive they are. Dior and Prada both have couture, or handmade items.
But before we talk about the Dior issue, have you ever worn anything couture? My curtains are couture. My children’s uniforms had couture name tags. Couture implies completely sewn by hand. For my curtains, my godmother was a very good seamstress, but never learned how to use a machine. She had lived through the Depression and had always sewn by hand; the nuns at her school taught her how to make very exact, small, functional stitches. When I got married, she made the curtains for my bedroom. Similarly, she hand-embroidered name tags for my uniforms. I did the same for my children’s uniforms.
In couture, we see one of the challenges of industrialization, but Prada and Dior's recent use of AI in supposedly authentic animated videos highlights the real challenge of the concept of handmade. One thing that happens with mechanization is that it makes many things much more affordable; as products become more affordable, they no longer serve as a marker of prestige, while early mechanized sewing meant many more people could have more clothes. It also meant having lots of clothing was no longer a marker of class. At each of these moments, when other classes gain access to what was previously seen as wealthy, new benchmarks are assigned. So handmade clothes, once something that connected the rich and the poor, as there were no other options for making clothes, became a marker of wealth. But I should clarify: the very wealthy had luxurious handmade clothes, interestingly enough, until the late 20th century; in the US and Europe, the poor also had handmade clothes. But the poor often made them at home with machines; after all, they didn't need the cachet of exact stitches, and they needed clothing that could stand up to hard labor. People's labor is only visible at the very highest tier, and only to celebrate the buyer's status.
In the ad, they centered the work of a craftsmen to signal the quality of their brand. ** Dior** featured Oscar-nominated animator Sylvain Chomet, best known for “The Triplets of Belleville,” as the director of
The truly human aspect of this Dior snafu was hubris. When I saw the ad, I knew something was off. I can get fooled by AI, sadly, because, like most of us, I’m human. I thought it was AI, but I waited until many, many Redditors saw what I saw. Since I’m not an animation specialist, I knew I needed human support. The people at Dior marketing also weren’t animation specialists. Rather than being honest with themselves about their capacity challenges, they chose to lead with blind stupidity. They assumed their role at a brand of such renown would make them special enough to pull one over on people.
At Microsoft and Dior, we see the real challenge brands face: management has forgotten that their consumers matter. Value for investors is placed above value and respect for consumers. Human oversight is essential to ensure products are human-centered. People check machines. People ensure quality. But, most importantly, people with jobs pay for products. A system in which managers use machines they don’t understand will break repeatedly, alienate consumers, and put those managers out of work. The short-sighted greed of Microsoft and the foolishness of Dior are both the result of people making bad choices. Until people at the top realize humans are the customers, we’ll continue to see colossal acts of hubris and greed.
Unlike the previous Prada AI ad, Dior thought they’d get something more publicly acceptable by mimicking hand-drawing. But that was also their downfall, I’d say. Look at this ad with an eye out for the machine elements. Hands are usually a great tell, as they’re harder for AI to capture. The figures' movement also felt mechanical, which doesn’t occur in hand-drawn animation where people supervise every moment of movement.
Overall, what’s your take on the visuals? For me, using drawn elements with AI made the ad even more disappointing. It’s as if they used the drawings to trick consumers into thinking they remain committed to finding human-made products, while actually using machines. The whole endeavor seemed to assume the world is not as intelligent as those tricky smarties at Dior.