On the morning of Monday, June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein stepped into a Palm Beach County courtroom and pleaded guilty to two state felonies: soliciting prostitution and procuring a minor. Circuit Judge Deborah Dale Pucillo sentenced him to eighteen months in the county stockade. Under a secret federal Non-Prosecution Agreement negotiated by U.S. Attorney Alexander Acosta, Epstein had quietly pulled off an unprecedented legal escape, trading a federal grand jury indictment that carried up to forty-five years in prison for a short stay in a local jail, complete with liberal work-release privileges.
Hours before he walked through the stockade doors, at precisely 7:15 a.m., Page Six released his narrative maneuver for the morning. Eleven days earlier, federal prosecutors in Brooklyn had unsealed a landmark criminal indictment against Ralph Cioffi and Matthew Tannin, the managers of Bear Stearns' flagship mortgage hedge funds, marking the first criminal case of the global subprime crisis. Inside that indictment sat an unnamed figure, designated only as Major Investor Number One, whose sudden fifty-seven million dollar exit in April 2007 had shattered the funds' liquidity and accelerated their final collapse. Page Six filled in the blank for the public, reporting that according to sources, that investor was Epstein. Then came the line that established a decade-long media myth, citing his publicist Howard Rubenstein confirming Epstein as Major Investor Number One while offering no further comment.
The public narrative was instantly set. A disgraced billionaire heading to jail for child sex crimes authorized his publicist to declare him the mastermind investor whose massive run on the bank broke Bear Stearns. That statement was a complete lie.
Before the media play came the physical sham. At his sentencing, Epstein assured the court he would spend his days working for a non-profit called the Florida Science Foundation at 250 Australian Avenue in West Palm Beach, claiming he had been working there every day. Three days later, an Assistant U.S. Attorney sent a sharp warning to the sheriff's colonel in charge of the stockade, noting that state records showed the foundation was incorporated in November 2007 rather than years prior, that the address provided was simply defense lawyer Jack Goldberger's law suite, and that neither the building directory nor the door reflected such a business. The prosecutor dryly added that sitting in his attorney's office suite making phone calls, surfing the web, and ordering food delivery was hardly the intended objective of imprisonment. The Sheriff allowed it anyway, and by December, Acosta admitted to victims' attorneys that Epstein was out of jail twelve hours a day, six days a week. The Florida Science Foundation was nothing more than an empty law suite functioning as an offshore command center outside his cell.
To understand why Epstein engineered the cover story, one must look directly at the criminal paper trail of the April 2007 market run. Inside Brooklyn federal court, prosecutors laid out the precise mechanics of the collapse. On Wednesday, April 18, 2007, Major Investor Number One verbally warned Cioffi that it intended to pull its fifty-seven million dollars. Cioffi assured colleagues that he and his team had eight million dollars of their own money in the fund, while quietly concealing that he had already moved two million dollars of his personal wealth out weeks earlier. The following day, Major Investor Number One filed formal written notice demanding the full fifty-seven million dollars back.
By Sunday morning, Tannin panicked, emailing Cioffi from a personal Gmail account to a private Hotmail address to dodge internal Bear Stearns servers, writing that if their model was anywhere close to accurate, they should close the funds immediately because the entire subprime market was toast. On Wednesday, April 25, Cioffi hosted an emergency conference call with two hundred anxious investors and lied outright, claiming the next big redemption date was June 30th and that they currently had only a couple million dollars in redemption requests. By July, one point four billion dollars in investor capital had vanished, sending the subprime market into its fatal cascade toward 2008.
The crime charged by the grand jury was Cioffi's deliberate concealment of Major Investor Number One's exit, and the press routinely assumed Page Six had gotten the identity right. The truth finally emerged on November 3, 2009, during the final week of the criminal trial in Brooklyn. Federal prosecutors James McGovern, Ilene Jaroslaw, Patrick Sinclair, and Brian Sano submitted a filing to Judge Frederic Block. Outlining their legal theory of criminal intent, the government finally typed the real identity behind the exit, explicitly writing that the jury could find Tannin's efforts to tweak the fund's response to Concord as an artifice to defraud.
It was Concord, not Jeffrey Epstein, and not Financial Trust Company. Weeks later, Bear Stearns' attorneys at Kramer Levin exposed the illusion in an arbitration filing, noting that Epstein's penchant for lies was displayed when he authorized his publicist to claim he was Major Investor Number One. The filing made clear that Epstein never had anywhere near fifty-seven million dollars in the funds, and that trial transcripts had now proven to the world that the real major investor was Concord Management. Epstein's own confidential FINRA filings under oath confirmed the reality, as he admitted calling Bear Stearns co-president Warren Spector repeatedly in mid-March, mid-April, and mid-May 2007 demanding to pull his money, only for Spector to convince him to stay. Epstein never pulled the fifty-seven million dollars from the hedge funds; he had been talked into remaining trapped inside.
So who was Concord?
PAID SUBSCRIBERS CAN CONTINUE READING THIS CHAPTER BELOW THE PAYWALL.
