Did the photojournalist mean to make them look this stupid? When looking at photographs in news articles (this photograph was licensed by the Advocate), remember a few key aspects of news photography. Journalists are meant to share the news. While journalistic integrity seems to be waning in our era, ideally, they should present what occurred. Along with the text, photographers capture what happened. Many emotional aspects of events are hard to “tell” but easy to show. How would you say in the news article that the head of the Department of Homeland Security, a man who cowered behind a chair when adherents of Trump stormed the Capitol, looks confused and fussed with his hands? That would add bias, because we don’t know if he looked confused, worried, or just demonstrated the je ne sais quoi that is Markwayne. His face certainly doesn’t project confidence.
Mullin’s partner in crime, Sean Duffy, a man who was unlikeable from the minute he appeared on MTV with a head full of dippity do and a smarmy expression, offered many expressions, none of them cause for comfort.
The Jerusalem Post chose this Reuters image from Elizabeth Frantz, framed slightly below. While Frantz’ full slew of shots from the presser had more damning ones, this one isn’t particularly strong. Duffy seems dwarfed by the flag, and his frame obscures the White House graphic. His double zippers create an obvious“V” that draws your eye to his bare neck. Being forced to question what our transportation is or isn't wearing isn’t ideal as a citizen. Mullin appears to look offstage. His expression seems somewhat trepidatious**, **but I might be assigning feelings he’s not capable of. This image was paired with a fairly neutral headline, “US ground stop caused by aging equipment, no evidence of cyberattack, Transportation Sec. says”
In comparison, the Irish Star went with this image by Alex Brandon for AP. The framing centers Duffy, with the White House almost like a halo behind him. Rather than being dwarfed, the framing gives him all the credit, not in a way a successful person would want. His posture reeks of, well, posturing. Mullin is in the back, hands still fidgety. But now he’s looking down. Could he possibly be putting 2 and 2 together? The headline here is “Duffy’s awkward reaction and head shake as Mullin gives bizarre explanation for ground stop”
The journalistic elements, the article and the photographs, get framed by the presentation. Photojournalists choose what they shoot. They take multiple shots, often working for large organizations like AP. Editors pick those images and pair them with articles, sometimes written by the wire service or by their own journalists. Editors or headline editors often write the headlines. Notice how the image pairs with the title to evoke a mood.
I’m struck by the images that weren’t selected. One of my favorites from the set is one where you see an honest moment from Duffy, where he seems to hold back from the lie he could tell. Mullin is still looking down at the ground; maybe he’s wondering if Hell is just below the podium. I’d title this article The Truth of the FAA Shutdown, but there’s no way this administration would give us the content to run it.