Oconee County, Georgia, is an affluent county just outside Athens and is a good proxy for well-to-do white voters in Georgia. In 2022, seventy-four percent of its voters turned out. This year, only seventy percent did. Those who showed up gave Rick Jackson a margin of more than thirty-six points over Keisha Lance Bottoms, while Mike Collins beat Jon Ossoff there by only twenty-two points, according to 𝕏county results compiled after the election.
In Atlanta’s Eighth City Council District, which covers the western part of Buckhead where the city’s wealthy live, Ossoff beat Collins by nearly twenty-four points. Rick Jackson, on the same ballot and with the same voters, beat Bottoms there by four, according to 𝕏the same analysis. Jackson ran ahead of Collins virtually everywhere in the state, though neither won. Bottoms will be the first Democrat sworn in as governor of Georgia since Roy Barnes lost to Sonny Perdue in 2002, and Ossoff is headed back to the Senate.
Jackson spent the primary trying to connect himself to President Trump, even though President Trump had endorsed Lt. Governor Burt Jones. Jackson beat Jones anyway on the strength of his own résumé as a businessman who builds things and shifted to be a “Kemp Republican” in the general election. Collins, by contrast, ran as a Trump loyalist through November. Suburban voters noticed.
From Texas to Georgia, there is a pattern Republicans need to pay attention to.
The first part of it is obviously candidate quality. The data, now fully digested, shows that Ken Paxton really did drag down the rest of the Republican ticket in Texas. Senate Republicans warned for a year that a Paxton nomination would put the seat and everything below it at risk, and the President endorsed him anyway. Paxton crushed John Cornyn in the runoff and then lost to James Talarico, who will be the first Democrat Texas has sent to the Senate since 1993. Democrats gained ground all the way down the ballot. As 𝕏Patrick Ruffini has shown, Texas Republicans actually outperformed Georgia Republicans on turnout, but voters punished the whole state party over Paxton. A significant portion of Republican voters also voted against the GOP over Paxton.
The second part of the pattern is competence. Voters want competence. Instead, from the GOP, they got a great deal of inaction and incompetence, just as they got from Joe Biden. In Florida, Ron DeSantis and the Republicans around him have been ruthlessly competent, and they were not weighed down by a bad Senate candidate. Florida did fine.