For more than thirty years, I’ve accompanied people through religious deconstruction and the much longer work of rebuilding a life. Some wanted to explore spirituality after religion. Others found themselves up against nihilism, wondering why anything should matter once the reasons they’d been given had fallen away. Those conversations helped lead me to existential health. I kept meeting people who had become remarkably clear about what they no longer believed and still felt uneasy making an ordinary decision without someone they trusted telling them it was theirs to make.
Social media changed the conditions under which people do that work. It gave many of them a way to find one another at a time when leaving a church could mean losing almost everyone they knew. I’ve also watched influencer culture turn that need for company and understanding into a market for certainty. Someone whose videos helped you name what happened to you starts showing up every morning with a verdict on what it means. Before long, you know how they would read the text your mother just sent you, and their reading is in your head before you’ve had time to register your own.
Influencer culture breeds digital cults. They form around online personalities whose performance of intimacy makes thousands of strangers feel personally known. In these circles, what people call “drinking the Kool-Aid” looks like an obsession that settles into the ordinary rhythms of a day. You check what the creator thinks before deciding what you think. You defend them in arguments they’ll never know you had. When something they say troubles you, the first thing you put under scrutiny is your own reaction. For the person at the center, there’s money in keeping that relationship going, and a growing cost to saying anything the audience might take as a betrayal.
I spent years in a pulpit, and I make my living in part through what I publish online. I have reason to ask what happens when people grow attached to a voice that helped them through a difficult time. The test comes when they see something that voice missed, and have to decide whose account of their life they’re going to trust.
Imagine a reader telling me, “Your writing helped me leave Christianity. I still pray.” As a former megachurch pastor who now writes about life beyond religion, I know how readily I could make that second sentence into a problem. From the pulpit, I might have heard the first sentence as evidence that the person had lost their way. Now I could hear the second as evidence that they haven’t left far enough. In either case, I would have managed to make myself the authority on what their experience means.
I began writing about life after religion partly because I wanted people to take their own experience seriously. There is something disquieting about doing that work in public. Someone reads you at a time when they’ve lost a community, a way of understanding their life, and confidence in their ability to decide what comes next. Your words help them make sense of what happened. For a while, they may need to borrow your language before they have any of their own. Then comes a moment when their experience exceeds what your language explains. What happens between you at that point tells you something about the kind of influence you’ve had.
The old arrangement survives every change of vocabulary if someone else still gets the last word. Online, there is an entire economy built around getting that word and keeping it.
A person starts posting about something that happened to them. Their account is particular and unfinished, as most honest accounts are. Then one afternoon they say it with a little more contempt and a great deal more certainty. That version travels. Strangers repeat it back to them. Invitations arrive, the mailing list grows, and eventually the attention has a dollar value. There’s a sponsorship to renew or a paid audience expecting something tomorrow. By the time the creator feels obliged to give a verdict on events they barely understand, a voice they once used to tell the truth has become a voice they rely on to make rent.
There are honest ways to earn a living in public, and I depend on readers who pay for my work. That gives me a stake in this question. I get to see which pieces bring in subscribers, and I know what it’s like to take a sentence I’ve been working on and wonder if it would travel further with a harder edge. Sometimes the harder sentence is the truer one. Sometimes I would be removing the very thing that made it true, a qualification that leaves room for a person whose experience complicates my argument. The numbers tell me which version traveled. They have nothing to say about the person I left out.
We used to call it selling your soul. The phrase sounds dramatic, but what it describes often happens by degrees. A creator learns to turn grief into material before they’ve had time to grieve. They hold on to a feud because it keeps them visible. The opinion they expressed last year becomes part of the product, and the people who pay for it have little reason to welcome a revision. Even notoriety has commercial value if enough people come back to see what the creator will say next. Eventually a person who made a living by being recognizable finds that it costs them money to change.
The pressure to become extreme follows from this. When the audience grows around a grievance, there’s a reason to find another offense before the last one loses its charge. An admission of uncertainty gives people less to rally around. A public humiliation gives them a scene they know how to enter. Soon enough there are people in the creator’s actual life who have to wonder whether a difficult conversation will be worked through in private or turned into a story for strangers. The damage reaches well beyond the person who earns the money.
Consider a woman who has left a church where she spent twenty years. Her mother calls to invite her to a service where the names of people who died that year will be read aloud. Her father’s name will be among them. She wants to hear it spoken in that room. She also knows how quickly people there might read her presence as a sign she’s coming back. There’s a real decision to make, and it belongs to the life she has actually lived.
By the time she gets off the phone, she has heard enough from the people she follows to know what the approved versions of her decision sound like. One voice would call the invitation manipulation. Another would tell her that going back would prove how much she’s healed. Either reading might catch something real. Both are remarkably easy to deliver when it’s somebody else’s father whose name will be read. What she needs is enough room to consider her grief, the history with her mother, and the cost she’s willing to bear to be there. A ready-made verdict spares her that difficulty at the precise moment when facing it would make the decision hers.
That is one way influencer culture reaches into private life. Its language arrives so quickly that you start with a judgment about your experience before you’ve had much of a chance to experience it. A deconstruction feed supplies a diagnosis of your family. A nihilist account lends you the contempt you need to get through an evening when the things you care about feel embarrassing. The next day, your family is still your family, and what embarrassed you still matters. Only now you have a public vocabulary that makes it harder to admit either one.
There is a social cost to revising those judgments. People find real companionship in communities gathered around shared language. If that language is what made you intelligible to others after years of feeling alone, departing from it takes more than intellectual courage. You have to risk finding out how much of the affection was for you and how much was for the version of your story everyone knew how to tell.
In my work on existential health, I keep returning to the relationship a person has with existence as they encounter it. Every account of reality, including one that helped us survive, is answerable to what we discover by living. It takes some capacity for uncertainty to leave an experience open long enough for it to disturb an explanation we’ve relied on. A culture that expects a verdict on everything by evening gives us very little practice in that capacity.
Self-authorship is the practice of taking responsibility for the judgments by which we live. It involves borrowing language, learning from people who see things we miss, and changing our minds when their account explains more than ours does. It also requires being able to ask what evidence would alter our view, including when we’ve already announced it and people are counting on us to keep it. The effort is in letting what happens have a say, especially where our identity and our loyalties are implicated.
In , I write about how we learn to trust our own judgment after years of looking elsewhere for permission. One of the harder parts is staying open to what others have to teach us while taking responsibility for what we come to believe.
I turned this question on myself in , where I asked what happens when my voice becomes so familiar that a reader hears it before they’ve had a chance to hear themselves. In
There is a corresponding responsibility for anyone who influences others. I call the person who takes it seriously the un-influencer. An un-influencer uses their influence to make your judgment less dependent on theirs. They have something to say and are willing to show you how they came to believe it. When your experience exposes a limit in what they’ve said, they take an interest in what you’ve seen. You learn something about their intentions by watching what happens to your standing with them after a disagreement.
The role carries a particular risk online. Humility has commercial appeal, and it would be easy to sell yourself as the rare person on the internet who gives people permission to think. The better test happens in the ordinary life of a community. If someone corrects you, is the correction visible to the people who heard the original claim? When a longtime member changes their mind about something the group takes for granted, are they still invited into the conversation? People notice what happens to the first person who takes that risk. They learn from it how much of themselves they’re free to bring.
Influence carries obligations. Anyone who asks others to take their words seriously owes them enough of the reasoning to examine those words for themselves. A correction belongs where the original claim was heard. When a change of mind costs someone standing with an audience, that audience gets to see whether the person it trusts is still free to learn.
Making a living in public should leave a person room to become someone their audience never asked them to be. An un-influencer lets a feud end while it’s still drawing a crowd and gives private grief time to be lived before deciding whether to tell the story. They honor the privacy of people whose lives cross their own, even when those lives would make good material. Some experiences belong first to the people who have to live through them.
The people on the receiving end of influence have a claim to the same freedom. A reader who found words for their pain in someone else’s work is free to outgrow those words. A person who found companionship in a community is entitled to bring an experience that unsettles what the group believes. The test of that belonging comes the first time someone risks telling the truth as they see it and waits to find out whether they’re still welcome.
An un-influencer uses their influence to make other people’s judgment less dependent on their own. The work has done something worthwhile when a person goes back to the particulars of their life, notices what the teacher missed, and trusts themselves enough to act on what they see. They owe no one a lifetime of agreement for having helped them once.
When I think again about the reader who still prays, I’d want to hear what happens when they pray. I might learn that it’s the only time in the day they’re able to say their dead brother’s name aloud. Or they might describe an old fear they’re still trying to appease. Those are different experiences, and even that much would be mine to learn from them. The word prayer tells me surprisingly little about what is going on in the room.
I write because I want what I’ve seen to be of use to other people. I still have to reckon with the temptation to recognize its usefulness by how much of my thinking I hear in theirs. If someone tells me a piece of mine helped them, I’m glad to hear it. I hope there will also be a day when they find something in their own life that my writing leaves out and trust themselves enough to tell me. They shouldn’t have to spend the rest of their lives agreeing with the person who helped them once.
If this article gave you something worth thinking about, I’d love your help making room for more work like it. A paid subscription is $50 a year. It helps me keep my writing open to everyone and build the field of existential health. It also includes membership in the ** Center for Non-Religious Spirituality**, where these conversations continue in gatherings, workshops, and the Daily Reader.