Compiled by Athena Smith.
Articles
AI Can (Mostly) Solve Cyber Regulatory Harmonization and Efficiency
Jay Healey and Benjamin Pearl argued that often-burdensome cyber regulations should instead seek to create regulatory harmony, allocating resources toward safety rather than compliance. Healey and Pearl contended that unwieldy regulations generate a “harmonization tax”—the cost of addressing compliance tasks—which overwhelms companies but generates little pay off in security. The authors analyzed the benefits of using artificial intelligence (AI) systems to streamline regulations.
Regulators and the White House should avoid the bureaucratic stress and political capital needed to eliminate duplicative and burdensome regulations, since AI can meaningfully share the cognitive and box-checking workload demanded by regulators. Instead, they must ensure that regulations do not conflict with one another, a problem no amount of AI can resolve; that regulations meaningfully enhance security; and that future regulations are as AI-friendly as possible, encouraging its use to streamline compliance.
Courts Are Striking Down Warrantless Flock Camera Use
Matthew Tokson outlined how automated license plate readers (ALPRs) likely violate the Fourth Amendment in the absence of a warrant. Although up until recently courts held that ALPR systems were legal, Tokson detailed how the Supreme Court’s ruling in Chatrie v. United States—which held that a warrant is required to obtain data from Google Maps—has guided lower courts in echoing these concerns with ALPRs, which can expose extensive location data.
Yet recent changes in the use of ALPRs and modern Fourth Amendment doctrine suggest ALPRs might be unconstitutional after all. Earlier this month, a federal court in the Northern District of Oklahoma declared for the first time that warrantless ALPR use violates the Fourth Amendment. More such holdings may follow, because modern ALPR systems have the potential to pervasively track people’s movements and facilitate police abuse in ways the Supreme Court has already declared unconstitutional.
Podcasts
Lawfare Daily: Anthropic’s Safety Mission vs. Public-Company Pressure, November 10: Kevin Frazier sat down with Roberto Tallarita to discuss Anthropic’s recently filed s-1, the company’s experiment in corporate governance, how to maintain a commitment to safety precautions even when that is in tension with profit, and more.
*Support *Lawfare
*Follow us on Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, and LinkedIn. Become a material supporter on Patreon. Sign up to receive *Lawfare