Compiled by Athena Smith.
Articles
After Good Faith: Intelligence Oversight in the New Congress
Julia Curlee argued that the war in Iran was a policy failure—not an intelligence failure—and that voters held the White House accountable for it, giving Democrats control of both chambers of Congress in the midterms. Curlee maintained that the Iran war followed a year in which the White House dismantled the institutions that should have warned President Trump against it. She contended that the new Congress should investigate this damage and enact statutory reforms to protect intelligence analysis and personnel and keep the intelligence committees informed.
Congress has long deferred to the executive on foreign policy. That deference rests on an assumption of good faith, and it cannot extend to a president who ignores and stifles the institutions Congress authorizes and funds. Nor will that deference likely survive an administration that has conducted operations of questionable legality while claiming sweeping executive authority to withhold the information oversight requires. The new majorities cannot guarantee this never happens again, but they have the tools, and a mandate, to make it far less likely.
Back to the Future: The U.S. Court for Berlin’s Lessons for the ATRC
Aaron S.J. Zelinsky drew on the history of the U.S. Court for Berlin to apply lessons to the newly-revived Alien Terrorist Removal Court. Zelinsky outlined the history of the U.S. Court for Berlin, an Article II court established to exercise jurisdiction over West Berlin but which convened only once for a plane hijacking case, United States v. Tiede. Zelinsky examined what Tiede can reveal about the independence of Article III judges and argued that a court without precedent faces novel problems at every step.
A closer look at that forgotten court illuminates the potential future risks the United States faces using the ATRC, and underscores a phenomenon made clear in the Guantanamo proceedings as well: Orderly judicial proceedings rest on generations of precedent and practice, and standing up a new court—especially one involving sensitive national security issues—often is much more complicated than it appears at first glance.
Addressing Iran’s Plutonium Pathway
Bailey Schiff argued that a future nuclear deal with Iran should close off the country’s plutonium pathway, which runs through the spent fuel at the Bushehr Nuclear Power Plant. Schiff explained that Iran’s development of a plutonium weapon could be slow now but has the potential to accelerate, especially with the help of Russia, although it remains to be seen if Iran has the necessary reprocessing capability, specialized equipment, or expertise to build it. Schiff held that Washington should constrain this pathway by seeking a deal to suspend Iran’s plutonium reprocessing activities.
Today, Tehran’s path to a plutonium weapon would be slow and detectable, limited by the difficulty of scaling up reprocessing, acquiring controlled equipment under sanctions, and rebuilding lost weapons expertise. But with enough time and will, Iran could erode these barriers, and if its relationship with Russia deepens, Moscow could ease that effort rather than obstruct it. Once negotiations resume, Washington should constrain the plutonium route by committing Iran to ship out spent fuel and accept a verifiable ban on reprocessing.
Podcasts
Lawfare Daily: The Trials of the Trump Administration, November 6: Benjamin Wittes sat down with Molly Roberts, Roger Parloff, Anna Bower, and Eric Columbus to discuss the latest litigation over Trump administration policies, including D.C. and Virginia’s suit to block construction of the triumphal arch, the Ahmed Soliman case, the politicization of the Justice Department, election litigation in California and Alaska, President Trump’s defamation suit against the Wall Street Journal, and more.
Videos and Webinars
Lawfare Live: ** Seduction, Intelligence Gathering, and the Allegations Against Nvidia CEO: **At 3:30 p.m. ET,
*Support *Lawfare
*Follow us on Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, and LinkedIn. Become a material supporter on Patreon. Sign up to receive *Lawfare