Wow, that whole Trump-and-forgiveness thing stirred up a hornet’s nest. The thing that fascinates me the most about it is what it revealed about different Christian theologies. But first, let me clear something up.
When I called Trump our “first post-Christian president,” I thought I made it clear in the piece what I meant. Many of y’all read it is “our first non-Christian president.” That’s not it at all. I don’t doubt that we have had presidents who weren’t Christian in any meaningful sense. I doubt Obama was any kind of believer. John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, and John Quincy Adams were all Unitarians who rejected the divinity of Jesus. Whether or not Donald Trump qualifies as an actual Christian was not at all my point.
No, the point I was trying to make is that Trump’s brutally honest statement about how defining his anger is to his character is so, so symbolic of our times. Of course we have had angry presidents before, just as we have always had angry people, driven by their rage. We always will. That’s completely beside the point.
Here’s what I was thinking about. A professor friend observed to me recently, “This country is full of angry people.” In context of our conversation, his point is that we are at a point in the life of our country in which so many people choose to identify themselves through their anger, and their capacity for anger. I quoted at length that far-right pastor, Andrew Isker, who wrote an entire book in which he counseled his readers to cultivate and purify their hatred. We see it everywhere.
If I were to teleport from 1988 (say) to the present, and see Americans everywhere not only celebrating the murder of Charlie Kirk, but priding themselves on it, broadcasting their hatred to the world on social media, for the approval of their peers and strangers, I would think that something extremely wicked had happened to my country. We have it on the Right too. It’s everywhere. And hey, there’s a lot to be angry about! Nobody doubts that. Anger is a sign of authenticity and commitment these days.
In a Christian society, though, this is something that we would naturally be ashamed of, or at least do our best to master it. This is what Christianity teaches, and not in a sappy “be nice to everybody” way. Christianity warns that our passions can control us if we don’t find a way to overcome them, via prayer, fasting, and repentance, opening ourselves up to the action of divine grace. Dante’s Inferno is filled with the damned; what damns them is they allowed themselves to be defined by their ruling passions: anger, lust, greed, and whatnot. A man of reason, both Christian and in the Greek philosophical tradition, is not a man without desire (we’re not Buddhists), but a man who can control his desires, instead of being controlled by them.
That’s not us anymore. Until what seems like the day before yesterday, none of us would have admired a man — especially someone of the elite leadership class, and especially the President of the United States — who openly and casually admitted that he would choose Hell before surrendering his vengeful anger towards his enemies. But this week, when Trump said it, so many of his supporters defended it as “honest,” and attacked people like me who said there is something very, very wrong with this.
A man who is so given over to anger is a man controlled by events. Reading about how the president makes decisions based on his “gut instincts” is not reassuring under any conditions, especially not now knowing, by his own admission, that he bears grudges in this way.
▶Take a look at this video interview with Democratic strategist James Carville, two weeks ago. He admits that he has “Trump Derangement Syndrome,” that he hates Trump, and embraces that hatred. Look, I completely get that a professional Democratic politico would feel this way. But it’s ugly. It’s really ugly. I was talking this morning to a Democratic friend who pointed me to this interview, and said how much it bothered him. My friend is thrilled that the GOP got whomped, but he said, of the Carville video, “I don’t want a politics like that.” Exactly right. My friend is an Orthodox Christian. I don’t know how he reconciles his Christian beliefs with supporting the Democratic Party, based on its positions, but that’s beside the point. The point is that as much as he, personally, despises Trump, he knows that Our Lord tells him to resist the passion of hatred. And he also understands how terribly destructive it is, and would be, if we embraced a politics of hatred.
Let’s recall a historical example. In the aftermath of the Versailles Treaty defining the terms of peace between the World War I combatants, French President Raymond Poincaré was so filled with rage at Germany for what that nation did to his own during the war that he was a complete maximalist regarding war reparations. Though Poincaré was a trained economist, and knew that this policy would bankrupt Germany, make it even less likely that the Germans could afford reparations, and lead to God knows what politically, he was controlled by his anger. David Lloyd George, the British prime minister, noted at the time that Poincaré’s rage at the Germans, however justified, was causing the French president to pursue a relentless policy that would not only fail to achieve the goal Poincaré wanted, but actually stood to make things worse not only for Germany, but for France.
And so it proved. The point here is not that Poincaré’s anger at Germany was unjustified. It was justified! The point is that it blinded him to reason, and even to the good of his own country — with utterly catastrophic results.
This is personal to me. Many of you readers will recall the story from 1994, in which the day we buried my grandfather (my dad’s father) in Louisiana, poltergeist activity started at my mom and dad’s house. It was all centered around my dad. Eventually Dad let me call Father Termini, an exorcist I knew, who drove up from the bayou with his prayer team. It’s a stunning story how they discerned the cause of it all, but I won’t tell it again here; you’ve all heard it. The point is, they figured out, though knowing nothing about my father’s history with his own dad, that my grandfather’s spirit could not move on until my father forgave him.
I instructed my dad to tell the priest and his prayer team to tell the story about the painful last three years of my grandfather’s life. Grandfather had betrayed his only surviving son, my father, in a way that broke my dad’s heart. Yet my dad stayed loyal, and worked through the pain to help his ailing father. After the old man’s death, Grandfather somehow could see how badly he had wronged my dad — and lingered, begging his forgiveness.
I don’t have a theological category to explain this, but I know it happened, because I saw it, and experienced it. The priest told my father that until and unless he forgave his father, he would still have these problems. My dad said he forgave his father. The priest blessed the house, said a mass for my grandfather’s soul (though the family wasn’t Catholic), and that was the end of the trouble.
I was so thrilled that my father, a world-champion holder of grudges, had experienced personally the power of forgiveness. For myself, this was the first time I had seen that forgiveness isn’t just a moral act, it is an act with concrete spiritual consequences (as is its withholding). And yet — and yet! — some years later, when a cousin of mine who had wronged my father approached him, apologized, and asked for forgiveness, my dad refused.
I was shocked! I reminded him of what had happened with Father Termini. I reminded my dad that he considers himself a Christian. Your nephew, I told him, admitted he had wronged you, and asks for your forgiveness. “You *have *to do it!” I said.
“OK,” my dad said, grudgingly. “I’ll forgive, but I won’t forget.” Well, I don’t know what was in my dad’s heart then, but I’m pretty sure he didn’t forgive. He spent the next fifteen years of his life on this earth estranged from his nephew. How terrible this was.
And then, when I returned to Louisiana with my wife and kids, my father was thrilled. But, as you all know, he (and the rest) refused to forgive me for the “sin” of having left in the first place, and for being different from them. To them, it was in the natural order of things that they should offer us only limited acceptance. I didn’t ask forgiveness for moving away decades earlier, or for being different from them — I had done no wrong, and in any case, if I had, dropping my life on the East Coast and returning to a tiny Louisiana town out of love for them all was as much “repentance” as they could have hoped for.
It made no difference. None. And it destroyed my health, my marriage, and my own little family. To this day, my mother blames me for being resentful of all this. To her way of thinking — the way of my Louisiana family — the way they behaved towards us made perfect sense. There’s a reason that when I moved back to America, I did not move to Louisiana, to be near her. I have pushed through the deep anger I have toward her, to try to be Christ to her as best as I can in these final years of her life. I don’t do it out of normal filial love for one’s mother; I do it because Christ asks it of me.
When I was living there and going through this crisis of the dissolution of my childhood family bonds, and the related dissolution of my marriage, I had to go often to confession, to confess my anger at them. I remember my priest telling me that I had to work as hard as I could to forgive. He wasn’t saying that I had to allow them to insult me or anything, but that I should remember that Jesus loved me, to the point of giving his life for me, even though I failed him through my sins every day. That was a hard saying, but I knew I had no choice, as a Christian, but to take this hard path of love.
I hated it, but I did it anyway, out of obedience. And because of that, I was able to be present on the day in the spring of 2015, a few months before my sick and declining father died, when he apologized to me for the way he had treated me all my life. And I was able to spend the last week of his life sharing his bedroom, with him in home hospice care, giving him his morphine, reading to him, rubbing lotion in his feet, inviting friends to come say their goodbyes, and holding his hand when he took his last breath.
Just the other night, when my friend was visiting from Knoxville, we were talking about how strange life is that way. If I had never returned to Louisiana with my wife and kids, would I still be married today? Maybe, or maybe something else would have happened to break the marriage. If I had not gone back, though, and if I were still married, I would be tormented by guilt over having moved away. It would have been pointless, but that’s how I am. There’s no way to know how it would have turned out. Still, I am grateful that the priest pushed me to live forgiveness towards them all, however imperfectly, and despite their lack of remorse. Not only did it open the door for me to be present for my dad’s own repentance in his final months, but it helped me to disentangle myself from the deep anger I had that was feeding my chronic Epstein-Barr.
I bring this all up, though, to highlight the terrible, terrible disaster that came from my father’s, and my family’s, refusal to let go of their foolish grudge against me. With my sister dead, the only way our line was going to continue there in West Feliciana Parish — something my father prized above almost anything — was if they welcomed us back and integrated us into their lives. But they refused. Now, the family is shattered, and almost nobody of our line lives there anymore. I’m in touch with none of them, which is how they want it. When my brother-in-law, my sister’s widower, retires in a few years, I expect he will sell his house and move away to live near his married daughter and her children. And that will be the end of our line in West Feliciana, after five generations.
All because of a refusal to forgive. The utter stupidity of all this destruction, my God. But see, the way of my father and my sister, who dominated our family system, was to define themselves by their grudges. It was a matter of honor. It is shameful to admit that you were wrong, or to appear to admit that you had been wrong. What makes it so complicated is that they were both, in most respects, good, moral, and generous people. But hey, that’s how it is among the Scots-Irish. That same priest who was my confessor told me that the thing that struck him most about life in the South (he had moved from the Pacific Northwest) was how intensely people there held on to grudges. I hadn’t realized it at the time, but after he said that, I thought about it, and it made sense.
Watching one of the final episodes of “Mad Men” last night, there was a comic scene in which the headmaster of a rich kid’s school picks a fight with Pete Campbell, because back in the Auld Sod, a Campbell had betrayed one of his own clansmen, a MacDonald, back in 1692. Pete and the MacDonald come to blows over it. It’s a funny scene, these high-bougie Yankees fighting over a 300-year-old grudge, but when I saw it, I thought: yep.
Anyway, consider what it means to have a man who is so captive to anger holding supreme executive power. I’m telling you, a lot of Republicans today who think Trump’s response to Ross Douthat was just fine are going to think twice when the Democrats take the White House, as they inevitably will, and rely on their unshirted rage at Trump and his allies to punish them. You don’t have to have read your René Girard to know where this cycle of violence can lead.
If you have the time, I invite you to read this astonishing New York Times Magazine story from 1999, about how the pre-Christian clan law of the vendetta has paralyzed life in rural Albania. Excerpts:
I have come to believe that a key ingredient of the Balkan poison -- perhaps the key ingredient -- is a different kind of schism, one that largely disappeared from the rest of Europe a half-century ago: that between urban and rural, between village and city. In contrast to all but the most isolated pockets elsewhere in Europe, the gulf of experience between the city and the village in the Balkans represents an awful chasm. The cities of Sarajevo and Belgrade are -- or were, until only yesterday -- emblems of European sophistication and cultural fusion. The typical Balkan village, on the other hand, has always been a hard and pitiless place, one where ancient feuds are nursed and passed on for generations, where change and outside influence is deeply mistrusted. What's more, so ingrained is the Balkan village's medieval code of honor and loyalty -- and this is true for Muslim and Christian villages alike -- that even many of those who have escaped its grip and become city dwellers seem to return to its thrall in moments of crisis.
More:
The collapse of the state and the national economy has led many Albanians to once again openly embrace the traditional laws and loyalties of the village. These are spelled out in the kanun (pronounced ka-NOON), a book of rules and oaths. By the dictates of the kanun -- there are actually several versions, most of which came into being centuries ago -- one's primary allegiance is to clan and community, not to the state. In accordance with this allegiance, taki…