This article outlines the little we know about the abuse of the Ukrainian soldiers detained near Kiev, and also why we know so little: the media’s whitewashing of the story and the wider problem of how NATO has used Ukrainian nationalists as a veto power to perpetuate a forever war. The argument being made is that the popular will and suffering of Ukrainians is denounced as “Russian propaganda” if it undermines the narratives required to continue the war.
The Event
On November 2, 2026, violent clashes erupted outside a Ukrainian National Guard facility in Petropavlivska Borshchahivka, near Kiev, following allegations that people were being unlawfully detained and tortured inside. Those detained were reportedly mobilized Ukrainian soldiers and deserters, who emerged from the facility with injuries.
The most dramatic video to emerge from the event showed a 14-year-old boy seemingly in shock as he was escorted out of the building. The boy had not been detained with the other men but had been one of the protesters who climbed on top of a wall. In an interview, the boy said that the soldiers operating the facility threw bricks at him and hit him with shovels, causing him to fall inside. Thereafter, he was pulled into the building for an unknown period of time, during which he was kicked, punched, and struck with shovels, while his clothes were cut with knives.
The facility was being run by Azov, a well-documented neo-Nazi unit that has since been integrated into Ukraine’s National Guard. Its insignia draws on symbols associated with Nazi Germany during the Second World War, such as the Wolfsangel and the Black Sun. The founder of Azov and head of National Corps is Andriy Biletsky, who had earlier declared his vision for Ukraine: “The historic mission of our nation in this critical moment is to lead the White Races of the world in a final crusade for their survival. A crusade against the Semite-led Untermenschen”.[1]
Human rights organisations have for years reported on the torture taking place in Ukraine, although with very little interest from the media. Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and the UN have written many reports about torture in Ukraine and Russia in the past:
“Ukraine: Abuses and war crimes by the Aidar Volunteer Battalion in the north Luhansk region” (2014).
[2]“Ukraine: Breaking Bodies: Torture and Summary Killings in Eastern Ukraine” (2015)
.[3]“Ukraine: Torture and Secret Detention on Both Sides of the Conflict Line” (2016).
[4]“You Don’t Exist”: Arbitrary Detentions, Enforced Disappearances, and Torture in Eastern Ukraine (2016).
[5]Joint Statement on Detention-Related Abuses in the Armed Conflict in Ukraine (2017).
[6]“Ukraine: Justice Needed for Former Secret Prison Detainees” (2018).
[7]“Arbitrary detention, torture and ill-treatment in the context of armed conflict in eastern Ukraine, 2014-2021” (2021).
[8]“Treatment of Prisoners of War and Persons Hors de Combat” (2023).
[9]“Treatment of Prisoners of War and Update on the Human Rights Situation in Ukraine” (2024).
[10]
There are endless videos of the ruthless conscription and “busification” of Ukrainian men on Ukrainian Telegram channels, and this brutal every-day reality is known by every Ukrainian in the country. However, the Western media has demonstrated little if any interest.
The Media Whitewashing: A “Pro-Ukrainian” Narrative Above the Truth
Western media coverage has been almost absent, and the little attention devoted to the matter has been aimed at whitewashing the incident and muddying the waters. The event is portrayed as a Russian disinformation campaign, with the focus on the boy’s participation in the protests being used to suggest that the entire event was staged. The Russian media jumped on the story for the same reason that the Western media ignored it: it discredits the authorities in Kiev. If something like this had happened in Russia, the situation would likely be reversed, with endless Western media coverage.
To turn the entire incident into a non-event, the recurring word used to dismiss the story is “unverified”, with reference to the beatings and torture. However, how can anything be verified in the current propaganda war? Will the Ukrainian authorities investigate themselves, or will Western media pursue any investigative journalism against their proxy army? Of course not. Any journalist who reported objectively would certainly be accused of supporting “Russian narratives”, and their career would be over. That is what journalism has been reduced to: a war of narratives to mobilise public support for war. The pursuit of truth is long gone. Thus, the predictable response from the media was to either ignore or whitewash.
NATO war propaganda dismisses any criticism of Zelensky as “anti-Ukrainian” and “pro-Russian propaganda”. Why? These are crimes committed against Ukrainians. However, this has been a consistent feature of the proxy war: ignoring the will and suffering of Ukrainians under the banner of “standing with Ukraine” against Russia.
Between 1991 and 2014, only approximately 20% of Ukrainians wanted NATO membership, yet they were pulled into NATO’s orbit as a “pro-Ukrainian” policy. In 2014, the toppling of President Yanukovych did not have majority support in Ukraine, yet NATO countries backed it as “standing with Ukraine”. Thereafter, Ukrainian opposition parties, media, culture, language rights, and the Orthodox Church have been purged with the eager support of the West, under the guise of liberating Ukrainians from Russia. These are Ukrainians whose rights have been taken away from them, yet anyone standing up for them would be smeared as supporting “Russian propaganda”. The Minsk peace agreement was sabotaged for seven years, the election outcome in 2019 was subverted, and the Istanbul agreement of 2022 was torpedoed under the claim of helping Ukraine avoid “capitulation”, irrespective of what Ukrainians wanted.
No Western journalists thought it was newsworthy that both the Turkish and Israeli mediators in Istanbul confirmed that the Ukrainians and Russians were close to a peace based on restoring Ukrainian neutrality, before the US and UK intervened as they saw an opportunity to weaken Russia by prolonging the war. Even Zelensky had stated in late March 2022, during an interview with the Economist: “There are those in the West who don’t mind a long war because it would mean exhausting Russia, even if this means the demise of Ukraine and comes at the cost of Ukrainian lives”. [11] Around the same time, in late March 2022, Niall Ferguson reported in
European journalists do not want to report on the polls showing that a vast majority of Ukrainians want immediate negotiations to end the war, as they are committed to the narrative that they are “helping Ukraine” by boycotting diplomacy, deporting Ukrainian refugees to refill the trenches, pushing Zelensky to lower the conscription age, and even pushing for the conscription of women. Political propaganda entails selling war as a selfless and altruistic objective. NATO is not helping Ukraine; NATO has built a proxy army and will fight to the last man. Yulia Tymoshenko, a former Ukrainian presidential candidate and longtime favorite of NATO, stated last year in a response to the head of German intelligence that “what we did not want to believe” has been stated so openly: “At the cost of the very existence of Ukraine and at the cost of the lives of hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians, did someone decide to pay for the ‘weakening’ of Russia for the sake of security in Europe?”
Political leaders think and act in terms of power politics, with the objective to revive the unipolar, hegemonic world order by using Ukrainians to knock Russia out of the ranks of the great powers, so the US can focus its resources on confronting China. Yet, the media consistently sells the war to the public as merely being about “helping” Ukraine.
Fascists as NATO’s Veto Power
The fascist groups in Ukraine are a small minority, yet they have disproportionate power due to how they exercise violence. The Western support for fascists is not the source of a shared ideology, rather it is pragmatism as the fascists are staunchly anti-Russian and highly motivated fighters. Much like the Western support for jihadists in Libya and Syria, the fascists in Ukraine are a means to an end. As Foreign Policy reported in March 2014, shortly after the coup: “The uncomfortable truth is that a sizeable portion of Kiev’s current government—and the protesters who brought it to power—are, indeed, fascists. [12] On 5 February 2022, less than three weeks before the Russian invasion, the leader of fascist organisation C14, Yevhan Karas, argued that the nationalists had been the decisive force at Maidan. Karas recognised that the support from the West was not altruism, rather the West backed them because “we have started a war” that was fulfilling the goals of the West: “we have fun killing and we have fun fighting”.
The nationalists then became a powerful veto power over any efforts by Ukraine to seek peace with Russia. Professor John Mearsheimer accurately argued: “The Americans will side with the Ukrainian right. Because the Americans, and the Ukrainian right, both do not want Zelensky cutting a deal with the Russians that makes it look like the Russians won”. [14] By 2020, the paramilitary constituted about 102,000 men, which was about 40 percent of the entire Ukrainian armed forces.
Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko went through an astounding transformation from an opponent of Ukrainian nationalism to one of its leading advocates. The BBC reported in August 2015 that a clear majority of 265 MPs out of 450 had supported the first reading of the decentralisation bill to grant more autonomy to Donbas. This sparked a violent veto by the far right, it then reported: “Protesters led by the populist Radical Party and the ultra-nationalist Svoboda (Freedom) party—who oppose any concession to the Russian-backed seperatists” clashed with riot police that resulted in the death of a national guard member and over 100 injured. [16] Poroshenko subsequently began to abandon his efforts to implement the Minsk-2 agreement.
Zelensky was also forced to reverse his position and bow to NATO’s nationalists. Zelensky won the presidential election in April 2019 with the pledge to make peace, running on a peace platform including establishing talks with Donbas, restoring normal relations with Russia, and implementing the Minsk-2 peace agreement. In an astonishing landslide victory of 73 percent of the vote, Zelensky achieved an immense Ukrainian mandate to resolve its conflict with Donbas and Russia. Following his election victory, Zelensky declared his intentions: “I think that we will have personnel changes. In any case we will continue in the direction of the Minsk [peace] talks and head towards concluding a ceasefire”. [17] The nationalists were yet used by NATO as a veto power to prevent peace from breaking out. Rallies against “capitulation” were staged, and Zelensky was rebuked and humiliated by the nationalists when he visited the front to call on pulling back the heavy weapons. Zelensky told the soldiers: “I’m the president of this country. I’m 41 years old. I’m not a loser. I came to you and told you: remove the weapons”.
The West provided its support to the nationalists by pressuring Zelensky with their government-financed “non-governmental organisations” (NGOs), which have been a key instrument of US intelligence agencies to infiltrate and hijack the civil society of other countries for decades. The most important being the National Endowment for Democracy, established by Reagan and the CIA Director in 1983, The “NGOs” published a long list of red lines, which essentially covered the majority of the peace platform that 73% of Ukrainians had voted for, which even included negotiating with Russia without the participation of the West. Below is the complete list of “red lines” [19]:
Who financed “Ukrainian civil society” that drew a big red line under the peace platform that the vast majority of Ukrainians had voted for? These are the donors [20]:
The simple reality is that Zelensky could not make peace even if he wanted to, as the Western-backed nationalists would march on Kiev if he tried. This is how you engineer a forever war. The Europeans still refuse to make peace without the approval of Ukraine, which now means Zelensky. None other than Boris Johnson recognised how the nationalists limit Zelensky’s power - although Johnson did not mention the relationship between the NATO countries and the nationalists.
To summarise my argument: We will likely never learn exactly what happened at Petropavlivska Borshchahivka due to the central paradox of this proxy war: under the banner of defending Ukraine, the suffering of Ukrainians is concealed, their democratic will is subordinated to geopolitical objectives, and those who expose these contradictions are denounced as enemies of Ukraine.
[1] T. Parfitt, 2014. Ukraine crisis: the neo-Nazi brigade fighting pro-Russian separatists,
[2] Ukraine: Abuses and war crimes by the Aidar Volunteer Battalion in the north Luhansk region (2014),
[3] Ukraine: Breaking Bodies: Torture and Summary Killings in Eastern Ukraine (2015),
Ukraine: Breaking Bodies: Torture and Summary Killings in Eastern Ukraine - Amnesty International
[4] Ukraine: Torture and Secret Detention on Both Sides of the Conflict Line (2015),
[5] “You Don’t Exist”: Arbitrary Detentions, Enforced Disappearances, and Torture in Eastern Ukraine(2016),
[6] Joint Statement on Detention-Related Abuses in the Armed Conflict in Ukraine (2017),
[7] Ukraine: Justice Needed for Former Secret Prison Detainees (2018),
[8] Arbitrary detention, torture and ill-treatment in the context of armed conflict in eastern Ukraine, 2014-2021 (2021),
[9] Treatment of Prisoners of War and Persons Hors de Combat (2023),
[10] Treatment of Prisoners of War and Update on the Human Rights Situation in Ukraine (2024),
[11] The Economist. ‘Volodymyr Zelensky on why Ukraine must defeat Putin’
[12] A. Foxall and O. Kessler, ‘Yes, There Are Bad Guys in the Ukrainian Government’,
[13] A. Rubenstein and M. Blumenthal, ‘How Ukraine’s Jewish president Zelensky made peace with neo-Nazi paramilitaries on front lines of war with Russia’,
[14] A. Maté, ‘Siding with Ukraine’s far-right, US sabotaged Zelensky’s mandate for peace’,
[15] P.K. Dutta, S. Granados and M. Ovaska, ‘On the edge of war’,
[16] BBC, ‘Ukraine crisis: Deadly anti-autonomy protest outside parliament’,
[17] BBC, ‘Ukraine election: Comedian Zelensky wins presidency by landslide’,
[18] O. Grytsenko, ‘‘I’m not a loser’: Zelensky clashes with veterans over Donbas disengagement’,
[19] Joint statement by civil society representatives on the first political steps of the President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky Оригінал статті - на сайті Українського кризового медіа-центру: https://uacrisis.org/en/71966-joint-appeal-of-civil-society-representatives,