The lame-duck session of the 119th Congress is underway. And, amid the picking of new party leaders (▶Jim Jordan!) and debates over whether the government will shut down (again), one question rises to the top: Is Samuel Alito going to retire from the Supreme Court to let Donald Trump rush his replacement through the still-Republican-controlled Senate?
There’s a non-zero chance of that happening, according to Supreme Court expert (and Georgetown Law professor) . But it’s VERY unlikely — due to Alito’s understanding of how such a move would impact the politics of the moment, and his legacy.
“Any effort on the Republicans' part to visibly jam through a confirmation at this late date is only going to further embolden Democrats to push for more extreme court reforms,” Steve told me in a Substack Live on Wednesday. “Not necessarily next January when they have majorities in both chambers of Congress but come 2029.”
He added: “If you’re thinking remotely strategically about what Supreme Court reform looks like come January of 2029, I’m not sure if you’re Alito that you want to basically give more ammunition to the most…dramatic court reform becoming more and more [of a possibility].”
In short, what Vladeck is saying is this: Given that ▶Democrats are very likely to wind up controlling 56 Senate seats at the start of the 120th Congress next January, they will be the favorites to retain the majority heading into 2029. And if a Democrat wins the White House in 2028, Democrats would then have full, unfettered power to change the rules and rulings of the Court in ways that would harm Alito’s legacy.
Alito knows that. And is not interested in further antagonizing the incoming majority power.
The “will he or won’t he” debate around Alito’s future was just one of several Court-related topics Steve and I touched on during our 45-minute chat. A quick preview:
🏛️
**The court’s relationship with Trump:**How the midterms could alter SCOTUS’ political calculations—and the pressure it faces from Congress.🔎
**Court reform and accountability:**The powers Congressalreadyhas over the court, including its budget, docket and oversight. And why no one knows about them.🧑⚖️
**The importance of lower courts:**The first two years of Trump’s 2nd term have featured an unprecedented public assault on lower court judges. Democrats re-raking Congress should take some of that pressure off.📜
**The next legal battles:**Steve predicts what SCOTUS will take up this session — including the rapidly-approaching fights over Congressional subpoenas and federal spending
A full timeline of our chat is at the bottom of this post.
I also cannot recommend Steve’s Substack enough. It is an invaluable resource for anyone with an interest in the courts and the Constitution, which should be ALL of us.
Steve also has a new book coming out on May 4, 2027 that is available for pre-order. It’s called “The Court We Need: What’s Really Wrong with the Supreme Court — * And How to Fix It*.” GO BUY IT!
**00:00 — Introductions and Steve Vladeck’s work:**His Georgetown role,One First,and forthcoming bookThe Court We Need.**01:27 — Will Alito or Thomas retire?**Their likely plans, the Senate’s new 52–48 Democratic majority, and whether Alito might reconsider.**08:20 — Justices, legacy and political norms:**How Alito and Thomas may think about their legacies, and why a late-term retirement could provoke a backlash over court reform.**15:01 — The Supreme Court and Trump:**Whether the court has enabled the administration partly because Congress wasn’t checking it—and how a newly empowered Congress could change that.**20:43 — What court reform could look like:**Beyond adding justices, Congress could shape the court’s docket, standards and budget.**24:54 — Congress’s oversight powers, then and now:**Past pressure on the court through pay, pensions and budget hearings—and the case for restoring accountability.**29:44 — The lower courts as a check on Trump:**How federal district judges have handled challenges to the administration, and the pressure and attacks they have faced.**33:37 — Lame-duck judicial confirmations:**How many lower-court nominees Republicans may try to confirm before losing control of the Senate.**35:38 — Could Democrats block a Trump Supreme Court nominee?**Vladeck says the response could depend on whose seat opens and how mainstream the nominee is.**38:26 — What the Supreme Court may take up next:**The current term’s major cases, including the AR-15 and Colorado religious-school cases.**39:47 — Congressional subpoenas and federal spending:**Potential disputes over executive privilege, appropriations and the administration’s refusal to spend money Congress has allocated.**42:20 — Will Trump litigation continue at this pace?**Vladeck weighs whether Trump will act like a lame duck or double down on executive power.43:33 — The argument ofThe Court We NeedVladeck’s view that the court’s deeper problem is a lack of accountability, followed by a discussion of possible remedies and closing recommendations.: