I’ve spent the past week roasting MAGA, and I won’t pretend it hasn’t been one of the more enjoyable weeks of my professional life. I already got to Ted Cruz and Mike Johnson. I’m still waiting on Tim Scott, who has been quieter than a church mouse who just found out the church voted blue. Tim will surface eventually, usually right after somebody assures him it’s safe. The beauty of MAGA is that the whole movement is built out of people who talk shit for a living, and every one of them left a paper trail. I could roast a different one every day until 2028 and still have to leave people on the waitlist.
Today’s lucky contestant comes with a little social psychology. If you study cults, you can practically set your watch by the bullshit that starts when one runs out of steam. The prophecy fails and suddenly everybody’s attendance record is under review. The faithful didn’t believe hard enough. The traitors ran their mouths. The people who stayed home are personally responsible for the end of civilization. The prophet, who picked the date and promised the miracle, will be leading the investigation.
In 1956, Leon Festinger and his colleagues published When Prophecy Fails, a study of a group that expected a catastrophic flood on December 21, 1954, and believed a flying saucer would rescue them. The saucer missed its pickup. Some of the most committed believers responded by going harder on recruitment. Imagine waiting all night for a ride that never comes and waking up the next morning ready to hand out business cards for the driver. That’s cognitive dissonance at work. Once you’ve sunk your identity and your credibility into a belief, getting somebody else to buy it can feel a whole lot easier than asking yourself why you did.
The part that fascinates me is how much work people will do to preserve one conclusion. For the people in Festinger’s study, the end of the world came with a date. They could wake up the next morning, look out the window, and see the neighbor’s Buick right where he’d left it. They still had one another to help explain why the Buick was there. MAGA has an even easier assignment. A congressional loss can be blamed on turnout, weak candidates, disloyal allies, or whatever app teenagers are using. Give Laura Loomer a phone charger and she’ll have an alternate explanation ready before the county finishes counting.
Then loyalty starts paying less. The people who used to keep one another’s secrets start comparing notes in public. The same folks who spent years insisting that internal criticism helped the enemy suddenly have a great deal to say about their colleagues, all of it suitable for screenshots. Somewhere in there, somebody who has spent the last three years telling you the fate of civilization depends on their podcast announces they need to spend more time with family. Laura Loomer hit nearly every one of those marks within 48 hours of the polls closing on November 3. If I assigned this as a case study, I’d have to take points off for making it too obvious.
Newsweek counted 119 posts on Twitter in under 28 hours, roughly one every 14 minutes. She started with “TikTok should have been banned,” because when voters hand you a performance review that ugly, the obvious thing to do is fire the app. In Laura’s telling, delete TikTok on Monday and by Tuesday a 22-year-old who can’t afford rent is suddenly standing in line to vote for Ashley Moody’s caucus. Yes, Laura, the algorithm did it. The Republican Party was one fewer video of a raccoon washing a grape away from holding the Senate.
The beauty of blaming TikTok is that it saves you the trouble of asking what young people heard when Republicans actually spoke. A voter can hear your argument, look at what it costs to live, and decide you’ve got nothing for them. Laura needs a Chinese app to explain how that happened. What was the backup plan if they banned TikTok and still lost? Put the raccoon under oath and ask who bought him the grapes?
From there she went to “I hate to say it, but America is over,” declared the country had been “conquered by communists and jihadists,” and predicted “massive political violence and terrorism” without offering a shred of evidence. By then she sounded like somebody live-tweeting a carbon monoxide alarm and getting mad at the batteries for being woke. Then she turned on the Christians.